Tuesday, January 24, 2017

Post Truth

Breakfast at the Rambagh Palace
Today was the last day of the Jaipur Literary Festival. We have been to dozens of panels. I write this blog to remember what we did, they all tend to blend together, this way we can relive what we experienced and try to put it into some sort of perspective. I have tried to document the referenced books. All of the sessions will be available on the internet for free. Some I will want to watch again, others are ones I missed, and will want to see for the first time.

The First Session of the day for me was ominously called: The Fall of the Rome and the End of Civilization. The obvious analogy would be is the American Empire going to fall, as Rome did. In short yes, all empires fall. We can only hope it is after we are gone. The book's author, Bryan Ward-Perkins suggested that the Roman economy became so diversified and specialized, that when there was a relatively small disruption the entire economy failed. He is illustrated this pottery. Discarded pottery does not deteriorate like organic matter. By analyzing the found shards of pottery the scientist could understand the ancient economy. It was a fascinating lecture.



I arrived early for the Travel Session and heard the last 5 minutes of the session entitled: The Girl with Seven Names. It is about a defector from North Koriea. Hyeonseo Lee was just concluding talking about the book. The audience rose to their feet in appreciation for what she has gone through. I knew I had just missed one of the highlights of the Jaipur Literary Festival. I have ordered the book and look forward to reading it. I also look forward to watching the video of the session when it is posted on the web. The few minutes I heard her talking were amazing, as she stated how she can’t trust anyone, for fear they are agents of North Korea.

The Girl with Seven Names - Hyeonseo Lee

We next attended the Travel Session. This session is repeated every year and I always attend it. They gather different travel writers who read short excerpts from their books. You get a wide variety of stories. My favorite this year, was by Simon Winchester. He read from his book: Krakatoa: “The Day the World Exploded: August 27, 1883”. I read this book years ago. When the volcanic island of Krakatoa exploded, it produced the loudest sound ever heard on earth. The  island simply blew up and disappeared. The book is fascinating. In the section he read, he had returned to Indonesia years after writing the book and experienced the growth of the island. It now was over 500 feet tall as the volcano re-asserted itself. It is bound to blow again. It was a beautiful piece of writing.

Krakatoa: The Day the World Exploded: August 27, 1883 – Simon Winchester

On a previous visit to India we visited the Sufi Shrine at Ajmer. This is a highly important shrine to the Sufi sect of Islam. Cathy and I have visited many Shrines and Temples and Mosques in India. They are everywhere. This shrine is the most important one in Sufism. For us, it was a bust. We didn’t enjoy the experience at all. They had a session on the shrine and a book launch of a new book on the Sufi Saint and Shrine.

The next session was on Sikunder Burns. It is late at night, and I am tired so I will simply borrow from Amazon the description of this new biography Burns. The author told us the story of the development of this book. We have read many books on the folly of war with Afganistan (they have never been conquered yet nations keep trying. It is the best proof that history keeps repeating itself. In Afghanistan ask: Alexander the Great, Russia, Great Britain, United States how they did, they all failed to concquer this land. Here is what Amazon says about this man and book: This is an astonishing true tale of espionage, journeys in disguise, secret messages, double agents, assassinations and sexual intrigue. Alexander Burnes was one of the most accomplished spies Britain ever produced and the main antagonist of the Great Game as Britain strove with Russia for control of Central Asia and the routes to the Raj. There are many lessons for the present day in this tale of the folly of invading Afghanistan and Anglo-Russian tensions in the Caucasus. Murray’s meticulous study has unearthed original manuscripts from Montrose to Mumbai to put together a detailed study of how British secret agents operated in India. The story of Burnes’ life has a cast of extraordinary figures, including Queen Victoria, King William IV, Earl Grey, Benjamin Disraeli, Lola Montez, John Stuart Mill and Karl Marx. Among the unexpected discoveries are that Alexander and his brother James invented the myths about the Knights Templars and Scottish Freemasons which are the foundation of the Da Vinci Code; and that the most famous nineteenth-century scholar of Afghanistan was a double agent for Russia.

Sikunder Burns – Craig Murray
The next session was on the Snowden Files. Luke Harding, the book's author, a Guardian reporter, told the story of Edward Snowden and how he and the Guardian received the information from Snowden. He is totally sympathetic to Snowden. He feels Snowden did all of us a favor by exposing how the US and Great Britain government are basically listening to ALL of our communication. Snowden, unfortunately for him, is caught up in the Donald Trump love affair with Putin. Snowden is currently residing in Russia and recently received a two year extension of his Russian Visa. The chances are that in some sort of grand deal between Trump and Putin, one of the things that Putin will offer to Trump is to return Snowden to the US for trial. He is a pawn in this game. If he is returned to the US he will be convicted and sentenced to a long term. He doesn’t deserve it. It is a shame Obama couldn’t bring himself to pardon 
Snowden. I feel so strongly about the work of The Guardian Newspaper that I have subscribed to the digital version.

The Snowden Files: The Inside Story of the World's Most Wanted Man – Luke Harding

Every year the Jaipur Literary Festival ends with a raucous Oxford-style debate. This year it was wilder and crazier than ever. The issue discussed was about Post-Truth. Much of the arguments back and forth referenced Trump, who is universally despised at the Jaipur Literary Festival. I never heard one word in his favor anywhere. In reality, I think it wasn’t a debate because everyone agreed, lies are being spread as they always have been. With social media they are spread faster and more broadly. There also is a concerted attempt by Russia, Trump and others to muddy the waters by asserting falsehoods. KellyAnne Conway’s statement yesterday about Alternative Facts played right into this narrative.


Like the rest of the world, the Jaipur Literary Festival had the aura of Donald Trump hanging over much of the discussions. The take away was that we have to oppose Trump's draconian policies in any way we can.

Tomorrow we leave Jaipur, we are ready to recuperate from this exhilarating, yet exhausting Festival.

No comments: